Welcome to my comprehensive guide on the Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms! Whether you’re a new mom navigating the world of breastfeeding or a seasoned parent looking to upgrade your pumping experience, this list shall have you covered. In this post, we’ll dive into the best breast pumps reviewed by moms who actually bought the product, providing you with the most accurate insights and recommendations to help you make the best choice for you and your little one.
Disclosure: This post contains links of which I would earn a small commission on qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. This helps me to keep the blog going and independent. All opinions expressed are of my own. Thank you!
Types of Breast Pumps
Broadly categorised, there 4 types of breast pumps: manual, electric, handsfree, wearable. Jump to your chosen category below:
- Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Manual
- Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Electric
- Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Handsfree
- Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Wearable
Not sure on the type of pump you need? Check out: Breast Pumps: How to Choose the Right One
Rating Data and Ranking Method
For product selection and ranking, we consider breast pumps listed in Amazon’s best-sellers’ list (as of April 2024). Product ratings and feedback are verified global purchases i.e. from moms everywhere, giving a more balanced view of how the product(s) perform across individuals. Only products with a minimum average rating of 3.5 stars and a minimum of 500 total ratings are considered in this list. Breast pumps listed in each category are in order of popularity.
(A) Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms : Manual
- Haakaa Silicon Breast Pump
- Medela Harmony Flex Manual Breast Pump
- Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
- Philips Advent Manual Breast Pump
1. Haakaa Silicon Breast Pump
While the Haakaa Silicon Breast Pump has been labeled a “manual” pump, this is actually the only patented, handsfree and noiseless pump that does its wonders by the power of suction alone. No hand pumping action necessary! Simply attach the pump to the breast and the silicon suction pump will do its magic via your breast’s let-down ability.
- Pros: Noiseless, handsfree, very portable, easy to wash and sterilise parts, great as a milk collector while breast-feeding.
- Cons: May not be as effective for moms with letdown or engorgement issues. Baby may try to knock off pump during feeding.
- Average Rating in Amazon (Global Rating): 4.5 out of 5
- Shop Now at Amazon
Here’s what moms are saying about Haakaa Silicon Breast Pump:
2. Medela Harmony Flex Manual Breast Pump
The Medela brand of breast equipment is one of the most established globally and a favourite amongst lactation specialists for their electric, hospital-grade pump (namely the Medela Symphony). The brand’s patented 2-Phase Expression feature, which mimics the suckling motion of infants, is also available on the Medela Harmony Flex Manual Breast Pump. This makes it the only pump in the world that simulates infant suckling, a feature that moms with engorgement or supply concerns truly appreciate.
- Pros: Very gentle on breast and nipple. Mimics infant suckling to promote/maintain milk supply. Different flange sizes available to better fit moms. After expressing, milk may remain stored in fridge with same bottle used for expression, or for bottle feeding
- Cons: Only comes with one flange at size 24mm. Other flange sizes and feeding teat sold separately.
- Average Rating in Amazon (Global Rating): 4.5 out of 5
- Shop Now at Amazon
Here’s what moms are saying about the Medela Harmony Flex Manual Pump:
3. Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
The Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump is another pump that offers 2-Phase Expression, with massage and expression modes to aid with let-down and milk removal. One may choose to pump directly into Lansinoh breast milk storage bags for immediate freezing, a feature that moms who pump exclusively will appreciate. Comes with 2 flange sizes (25mm and 30.5mm).
- Pros: Small, light-weight but durable material. Wide-neck milk storage bottles that are also easier to clean and transfer milk over to other bottles/storage bags
- Cons: May not be suitable for women with smaller breast/nipple sizes
- Average Rating in Amazon (Global Rating): 4.4
- Shop Now at Amazon
What moms are Saying about Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump:
4. Philips Advent Manual Breast Pump
Philips Advent is another popular baby feeding brand globally, especially in Southeast Asia. Technology and product quality of the Philips Advent Manual Breast Pump is comparable to brands such as Medela and Doctor Brown’s, but at more affordable prices. Many parents use the pumps together with the Philips Advent Anti-Colic Feeding Bottles, which are optimised to minimise nipple confusion and a comfortable feed for the baby.
- Pros: The soft ‘Floral’ design insert of the flange acts as a massager and gives a velvety and comfortable fit to breasts and a saviour for sore nipples and engorged breasts. Unique design allows moms to sit up expressing (no leaning forward required). Easy to wash parts.
- Cons: Insert may reduce suction power of the pump (but it is removable). No flange sizing, fitting depends on the insert’s compatibility with breast.
- Average Rating in Amazon (Global Rating): 4.4 out of 5
- Shop Now at Amazon:
Here’s what moms are saying about the Philips Advent Manual Breast Pump:
(B) Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Electric
Quick Links, and in Order of Popularity
- Spectra S1 Double Breast Pump
- Spectra S2 Double Breast Pump
1. Spectra S1 Double Breast Pump
The Spectra S1 Double Breast Pump is a hospital grade pump from Korea known for its milk production capabilities and affordability. It features several expression strength levels with programable intervals (or ‘sequences’), as well as different expression modes for a customised experience. In addition, this is one of the quietest electric breast pumps, important for moms who need to pump in the vicinity of a light-sleeping infant.
- Pros: Value for money with performance capabilities comparable to the Medela Symphony. Gentle on the breasts, more expression strength modes, quiet. Comes with rechargeable battery. Many compatible 3rd party accessories to choose from for an even more personalised pump experience.
- Cons: Heavy and bulky design. Comes with only 1 flange size of 28mm. May not suit mothers on the go or those without easy access to a private space.
- Average Global Rating in Amazon: 4.6
- Shop Now in Amazon:
Here’s what moms are saying about the Spectra S1:
2. Spectra S2 Double Breast Pump
The Spectra S2 Double Breast Pump is the latest version of the beloved Spectra S1. Like the Spectra S1, it brings the same hospital grade production abilities, default and customisable expression cycles, strengths and sequences. The newer version features a cute pastel pink colour and weighs slightly lighter than the S1 – the ‘girl” version of the same pump, if you will!
- Pros: Same as the Spectra S1.
- Cons: Retains the same bulky design. Slightly pricer than the S1
- Average Global Rating in Amazon: 4.5
- Shop Now in Amazon:
Here’s what people are saying about the Spectra S2:
Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Handsfree
- Baby Buddha Electrical Breast Pump
- Medela Freestyle Handsfree Breast Pump
1. Baby Buddha Electrical Breast Pump
With advanced motor features, portability, and user-friendly design, the Baby Buddha Electric Breast Pump is a game-changer in the handsfree breast pumps category. The pump features adjustable suction levels and cycle speeds, which mothers can personalise to mimic their baby’s natural nursing rhythm; and a super light rechargeable motor that is wearable with a lanyard (provided).
- Pros: The most compact portable electric pump (motor) in the market without sacrificing suction power. Compatible with other cups/flanges for customised pump experience. Perfect for moms on the go.
- Cons: Some may find suction power too strong, may not be suitable for engorged breasts or sensitive/sore nipples. Requires pumping bra for handsfree experience which is sold separately)
- Average Global Rating in Amazon: 4.3
- Shop Now in Amazon:
Here’s what moms are saying about Baby Buddha:
2. Medela Freestyle Handsfree Wearable Breast Pump
The Medela Freestyle Handsfree Wearable Breast Pump is the latest version of the ever popular Medela Freestyle series. The signature 2-Phase Expression mode pump is now upgraded to an even Hands-Free experience. Featuring the new breast shield collection cups cups (former versions came with flanges), Its discreet hands-free design allows mothers to express while multitasking or on-the-go.
- Pros: Improved hands-free experience, strong suction motor. Quiet. Able to pair with Personal Fit Flex flanges for personalised pump experience. Long battery life.
- Cons: Some find suction strength not as effective as with flanges. Has less customisation options for stimulation cycles and motor strength. Silicon membranes needs proper care to maintain suction strength.
- Average Global Amazon Rating: 3.5
- Shop Now in Amazon:
Here’s what moms are saying about the Medela Freestyle Handsfree Pump:
Best Breast Pumps of 2024 – Rated by Moms: Wearable
- Elvie Stride Hospital Grade App Controlled Wearable Breast Pump
- Elvie Pump – Single Electric Breast Pump
- Willow Wearable Breast Pump
- Mommed Double Wearable Breast Pump
1. Elvie Stride Hospital Grade App Controlled Handsfree/Wearable Breast Pump
Engineered with hospital-grade suction power, the Elvie Stride Hospital Grade App Controlled Wearable Pump ensures efficient milk expression while maintaining comfort for the user. The Pump is worn inside a nursing bra, allowing mothers to pump discreetly and comfortably without the need for holding external pumps or tubes, making it a true handsfree pump.
- Pros: Lightweight, quiet and very discrete. Powerful motor. Perfect for moms on the go/who may not have access to a private nursing room.
- Cons: Milk may leak /seep into tubing cords due to movement/when not placed correctly. No sensor to detect milk volume. Replacements cords are sold separately.
- Average Global Rating in Amazon: 3.8
Here’s what moms are saying about the Elvie Stride:
2. Elvie Pump – Single Electric Breast Pump
A fully cordless, wearable pump, the Elvie Pump features mobile app-control and quiet ‘invisible’ motor pumping, for the ultimate discreet experience. With a sleek flat shape cup shape and no cords to worry about, the pump fits into the mom’s bra leaving her total freedom in movement and activity. One of the best pump for working moms indeed!
- Pros: One of the most silent discreet pumps and flattest design available in the market (conceals the best).
- Cons: Pricey, have to stay upright to prevent spillage. Some may find suction power insufficient. Parts need gentle care and special sterilisation pills (no steam or UV sterilisation).
- Average Global Amazon Rating: 3.9
- Buy Now at Amazon:
What Moms are saying about the Elvie Pump:
3. Willow Wearable Breast Pump
The Willow Wearable Breast Pump is a strong competitor to the Elvie Wearable Breast Pump, boasting the same quiet and discreet experience. In addition, it comes with a long-charge time battery that supports mothers needing to express regularly, boosting milk supply as well.
- Pros: More discrete and quiet compared to traditional electric pumps, high charge battery. Hard flange instead of silicon, which helps some with milk production, more hardy and thus easier to wash and maintain.
- Cons: Heavier than other wearable pumps in the market.
- Average Global Amazon Rating: 3.9
- Shop Now in Amazon:
What Moms are saying about Willow:
4. MomMed Double Wearable Breast Pump
The MomMed Wearable Breast Pump is a popular wearable pump choice for moms seeking for the same freedom at a more affordable price. Relatively quite compared to other electric pumps, this product is a good addition to the traditional hospital grade electric pump to maintain production or light tasks around the home.
- Pros: More affordable pricing compared to Elvie and Willow. Decent production levels and battery charge. Lighter than many similar pumps.
- Cons: Not as discrete and quiet. More suitable for home or nursing room use.
- Average Global Amazon Rating: 4.2
- Shop Now at Amazon:
What Moms are saying about MomMed Wearable Pump:
What do you think of this list? Are there any pumps that have been missed? If you have any questions or feedback on this post, or any topics you would like me to cover, please feel free to send me a DM via this contact form or email tinyhivediaries@gmail.com!